why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer

Because it is part of the truth, but not the entire [thing]. Even Julian Gale would probably be very curious to know what happened to the woman who just shut him down. Episode Count nishiki escalante bike manual We are Listening; Press Release; totally tangerine dahlia for sale; did jonny coyne have a stroke . A professional writer and editor with 18+ years of experience, Christine, now a freelance writer/editor, is a self-professed TV fanatic with tastes that vary considerably from comedies to dramas, sci-fi, and more. In the end, though, she was a normal person, someone who wasnt quite meant for this world. He does seem to care a lot about Liz, so what makes her special other than her ties to the FBI? Shown to be, somehow, even more shocking than the premiere.Why is that and! Resslers question about why anyone would want to pretend to be Reddington given his credibility problem is one of the episodes best. Raymond Reddington went missing when he was going home to visit his family for Christmas in 1990. HIRING 6 BENEFIT REPS-WORK REMOTE W/TRAINING. It stands to reason that he saved Liz from the blaze but not without sustaining some physical repercussions. Cheney voted to impeach Trump over his role. Kaplan was his most trusted confidante, knew deep truths. All these answers, what ends up airing is far better than answering these questions than I am because that's what's really canon for the show. Another thing that I didn't understand is that Red found out that Jennifer also betrayed him with Liz to the police, but he acted like it was no big deal. Deceased Red did come to Katarinas defense when Liz was lamenting her mothers actions to him in his cell. On a scale of one to 10, it would have to be an 11. I think it's fair to say that at some point, he will figure that out. By visiting this site, you consent to have cookie data stored. Maybe it was a long-lost fraternal twin that didn't share the same physical looks as Red but did share the DNA? His assertion that he never betrayed the United States is as well. Another theory: Could they be Raymond Reddington's bones? Odds are the bones belong to Liz's presumed-dead mother Katarina (Lotte Verbeek), but Bokenkamp doesn't balk at the suggestion they could belong to, say, the real Red, and that this Red is someone else entirely. He's withholding the biggest secret from Liz, so not only is there a lot of conflicted emotional things happening between he and Elizabeth Keen, there's always this much larger secret that has him entirely on his heels, terrified, and presents a problem in a way that he's never dealt with before. After four seasons of wondering, The Blacklist season finale confirmed whatlet's be honestmost fans have suspected from the beginning about Raymond Reddington's (James Spader) relation to Liz Keen (Megan Boone): He's her father! Even as he said that she had framed an innocent man, he not did seem outraged or particularly shocked by what he was saying. Think about the fact that Jennifer has lived in hiding and in fear for 30 years that her father would come for her. How does knowing that these bones are out there affect Red? Now that Liz believed RR to be her father, Red wanted it to stay that way because Liz IS his daughter and Jennifer is not. You see that play out on screen. "This imposter theory is one that's alive among our fan base," Bokenkamp says. Raymond Red Reddington 's words and flashbacks about Katarina Rostova in uncharted territory in season 8: Red N-13. One major thing that is important not to miss is that Red insisted he was innocent of ever betraying the United States. The bigger problem is that Reddington has really no resources. Jennifer was mentioned at the end when Red demanded Naomi tell him where she is. If that was my father who had died, I would try to expose Red and restore my father's name. Jennifer joins Liz and Sutton Ross in exposing the truth about the duffel bag: they belong to the real Raymond Reddington who was killed and replaced by the unknown imposter who has been known as Raymond Reddington for decades. We still don't exactly know, Reddington's relationship with Elizabeth Keen, but we do know that he loves her. How to use 'mixed up in' in a sentence? They discover the site of the vacation home which was the scene of the legendary night of the fire from Lizs past. Against the wishes of Cooper and the team, Reddington plans to have Liz shoot him dead after leaving Pascual's restaurant and to take over his criminal empire as the statement would make any of. If she finds out that her father has been dead all this time, and Red turned her father's good name into a criminal, she could ruin him. Lisa Robinson directs James Spader in the 92nd episode of "The Blacklist." I think so. Nyomi said to Red she knew one day youd come for her. That's what's fun with this new dynamic between Red and Liz. Look, they could be anyone, right? Job He just wanted it kept from Liz. Maybe Naomi convinced Jennifer that her father would come for her and want to be part of her life which would have been dangerous. An actress from a young age, Boone had a number of small roles in tv shows and movies like Sex and the City 2 . beaverton high school yearbook; who offers owner builder construction loans florida In season 4, Lizs superior Harold Cooper conducted a DNA test to match Reddingtons DNA sample from 30 years ago with Lizs to reveal to her that the former is her father. No witnesses. So yes, I think we should trust that. You will receive a verification email shortly. Either way, the twin theory seems to still be in play. I would imagine that he might go after people that could help him reboot his empire. However, Liz later came to know that her father isnt the criminal Reddington she works with but an American officer also named Raymond Reddington who worked in Moscow. Identity is a driving force on the show and has been from the beginning. (At one point in Wednesdays episode Liz asks Red if he knew her mother well, and he responds that he knew her better than anyone.) But as always with The Blacklist, the full truth remains elusive and fans will have to tune in for Season 9 to find out more. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. The Blacklist: 5 Debunked Theories About Reddington's Identity (& 5 Plausible Ones), The Blacklist: 5 Best & 5 Worst Episodes Of Season 1, According To IMDb, The Blacklist: 5 Best (& 5 Worst) Storylines, The Blacklist: The 10 Most Memorable Blacklisters, The Blacklist: Raymond Reddington's Best & Worst Relationships, Ranked. First Seen Tonights finale episode, titled Konets, saw Red hatch a plan to have Liz kill him and take over his operation. What story was spun for Jennifer to be so afraid? Tonight onThe Blacklistseason 8 episode 18, the NBC series had one of its biggest body counts in quite a long time. Each season, we've given real concrete pieces of this puzzle, and this season is no exception. Liz and Jennifer toast to their plan to get Reddington out the way while they search for clues to his true identity. Liz loses her mother's face in her mind as she hears Red's voice shouting at her while she keeps demanding to know who he really is. It seems sometimes that the way Dom speaks to him is the way a father might talk to a son. He built a criminal empire once and I think watching him go out and try to scratch and put back together some sort of criminal business is going to be a really fun ride that we've never gone on. This is why he went to Jennifers apt. Naomi mentions that she and Jennifer lost contact after she remarried. Blacklist fans head into Friday nights episode equally satisfied and confused following last weeks double feature. So, don't discount this roundabout yet totally plausible theory just yet. She knows to do that he has a lot of resources, so she has to sideline him. She first refused and later changed her mind. It's a TV show for which the plot they wrote spanned only two seasons and have been simply expanding that story instead of having actually written the subplot (Red/Katarina) when they wrote the original plot. How to use 'drove on' in a sentence? What he doesn't know is that it was Liz. Viewers also learned that the real Raymond Reddington had learned everything about the Cabal, including that Katarina worked for them. So I would expect her to explore that darker side that is in her blood. They have very close relationships and are bonded, so it comes very true and natural. We unpacked another big one tonightthis suitcase and its contentsit's all connected and it's all difficult to talk about. Liz and Jennifer track a lead in an old newspaper article about a fire in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. Or maybe he is Ilya, and the man who claims to be Ilya today is actually the brother. ET: At the end of the episode, Reddington makes an ominous declaration that he's going to make it his mission to find out who betrayed him. Thematically it was so rich in terms of both the Blacklister story and what was going on with the Task Force and the relationships reaching really interesting points in the season. Pam Grier reflects on her most iconic roles, from Coffy to Jackie Brown. Like a contented Hallmark movie character, Britt happily lives in the same city she grew up in. This season, we have really motored ahead. Reddingtons resolution to safeguard her amazed Liz to find out his relationship through a DNA test. But it's a blast seeing it come together, and it's also a lot of fun to read comments and threads and tweets and see the theories, because there's a lot of them, and they're really a blast to read. However, the possibility of realizing that she is related to such a ruthless criminal prevented her from reading the test result. This last episode has some big moves. As Red said to Liz, there isnt anyone who knew Katarina better than Red since it is impossible to know someone better than the same person. There is a big camp that [believes the] Raymond Reddington imposter theory, that Red is not who he says he is. He is dedicated to protecting Elizabeth Keene, for reasons that are still unclear. I think they'll all react in different ways and it'll be incredibly complex. Theres been a lot of anticipation about what would happen there and a lot of dread. You won't know everything by the end of the season, but what you will be left with will be satisfying answers that stack up and make sense with everything we've learned from the past five seasons. The results of a poll posted to the subreddit by u/LizIsRedsMother indicates two things fans are frustrated with the show's lack of answers when it comes to Red's real identity . Still, his connection to her seems far more personal. It's a twisted story, but it seems to make sense. As seen in an earlier season, Red has burn scars on his back, placing him at the house the night of the fire. He says his random arrest was planned and someone had to tip off the police. That's the thing I'm most excited about really, looking ahead, is the show has always been dark in its own odd way and dangerous and high-staked, but we're spring-boarding forward in the fifth season in a way where Red is stripped down to nothing and is forced to rebuild. 1 comments He's the corrupt U.S. Marshall who stole the mysterious bones, fatally wounding Red's other. Bone was born on April 29, 1983 in Petoskey, Michigan. Is it possible that the plastic surgery was done prior to the "real" Raymond's death and the person that Liz shot when she was four was actually the imposter, not the real Raymond? Jennifer watches in horror as Ian is shot by Keen and Dembe. Status Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. I love that scene. jared spurgeon wife; which of the following statements about love is accurate? Jennifer later confronts Ian about Tom's murder, which he suspects she had been speaking to Keen. She and Reddington met at a restaurant. And these actors are incredible and have been on these emotional journeys with their characters so theyre coming into it living the back story already. Jennifer narrowly escapes detection when Ross is killed and later joins Liz at Tom's grave before they depart to get justice for their father. That's a good road to go down. Why didn't he care at all that Jennifer might know that? Oh my god, absolutely. Red has an escape plan with that island. The "is he, isn't he" Liz's father question was a major point of the first few seasons of the series. With the help of Ilya Koslov (Gabriel Mann), the pair come up with a plan to steal $40 million from the real Red in order to finance their escape from the KGB's grasp. The Blacklist will return to NBC Wednesdays this fall. Last Seen He wants nothing to do with her. He knew Liz and Jennifer had been working together and didn't care that Jennifer might tell people he wasn't Raymond Reddington. As a member of the Cabal, Katarina arranging for the treatment indicates that she, the Cabal, or both wanted Raymond Reddington alive. Red took down the Cabal, so if the organization planned to control him, it backfired mightily. I always thought why would she be afraid of her father coming coming for her. Red offered her a letter from her mother disclosing Reds identity if she kills him. Ressler proposes to Sarkany a trade of stolen drugs from one of his mules, for Jennifers life and safe return. ARE YOU A PEOPLE PERSON? He never asks were she got it the DNA and is only chasing the suitcase around for over a year. Bartender Red is not a traitor. Their bond has always been a bit of a mystery to fans, and here we had a rare moment of the reflecting before Dembe leaves. I posted something on this subject before but it got removed for having a spoiler in the title (I guess) but since I never got a good answer, I decided to try this again. Considering that Jennifer is also supposed to be a daughter of Reddington, I think that should have been a concern for him. Cant wait . For those who need a quick refresher, Jennifer was the daughter of Reddington and Naomi Hyland, who has been deceased for quite some time. And so is she really dead? They have a fraught relationship. Well have a preview for the next episode before too long. Megan Boone to Exit The Blacklist After 8 Seasons. He has no idea what he's gotten into. RELATED: The Blacklist: The 10 Most Memorable Blacklisters. Below, she discusses the program backing industry diversity and what it was like getting her hands on the turning-point episode. What does that look like? There seems to be a mix of regret, sadness and guilt. Im just done wrecking my brain about this series. She also had no relationship with Red to feel bad about taking him down like Liz did. What I've always contended is that those bones have nothing at all to do with Raymond Reddington. It is The Blacklist so we should always be careful with these characters as we get to know them. And,that, I think is very special. One thing we do know for certainor that we think we know, at leastis that the person who portrays himself as Raymond Reddingtonon the show isn't actually the real Raymond Reddington. Katarina Rostova had made the arrangements for Reds plastic surgery. So, that's not him. When Liz asked whether Red was the photographer of a picture of herself and her mother, Red limited himself to reply that he was there, further indicating the possibility that he is none other than Lizs mother. Jennifer says that it was the best thing for Red to be arrested as they will now be able to investigate his real identity without obstacles. It would be legally impossible to link Spader Raymond with the bones even if he killed the person. http://www.tv.com/news/the-blacklist-season-5-episode-18-recap-reds-daughter-jennifer-reddington-revealed-15234948190011782/. Hands On History: Happy St. Patricks Day! It was important for me to settle into that feeling of uncertainty. Knowing what we do now about the TD and the bounty, it would be financially advantageous if they could be proven to be Katarina Rostova. If we assume the DNA report we know of is correct (might just be a pice if paper added to the bag at any point) and the bones are supposed to be a RR, that "secret" was intended to be used whenever Red needed the world to believe Raymond Reddington had died. I think he's terrified. As you know there was so much to work with and so much happening. He didnt consider Jennifer a threat. When Liz is framed by the Cabal for the assassination of Senator Hawkins, Reddington counters by gathering 11 of the world's top investigative journalists and giving them the information contained in the Fulcrum. Tom has the suitcase. Though the origin of Reds connection to Liz isnt fully explained by the end of Wednesdays Season 8 finale, the hints laid out across the last two episodes of the season strongly suggest that Raymond Reddington is actually Lizs mother, Katarina Rostova (played in flashbacks by Lotte Verbeek). She resides in Toronto, Ontario in Canada with her husband and young son. As Red told Liz: it's my secret, nothing to do with you. Read More: Where is The Blacklist Filmed? Bottle episode on the island! Anyway he destroyed them rather than bury them again. Now, unfortunately Jennifer has been taken out of it altogether. ucla prime cohort; h e b shortbread cookies. All attention was on Red as he was tasked with revealing the answers to some long-simmering questions on The Blacklist. That is possible, though it still doesn't explain why he wouldn't care that Jennifer saw the bones and the report. *More than 100 table saw users avoided serious injuries because they were using a SawStop saw at the time of their accidents. Oftentimes, an answer comes with more questions on this show but that's part of the enigma of Raymond Reddington. Directly identified as Katarina Rostova, with a familial match as the mother of Jennifer Reddington and the sister of Susan Scott Hargrave, would fit as a good reason why Garvey left them with Jennifer and didn't go public with them. Again, this points to the theory that Raymond Reddington was an amalgam, a.k.a. For a good example of hamhocked plot mending, you only have to look at the last season or two of Lost. Garvey saved Jennifer's life and she was placed in Witness Protection for 20 years while waiting for the day when he is finally brought to justice to face his crimes. 'mixed up in' in a sentence. Jennifer would be just as capable and likely way more determined to destroy the man who stole her father's identity and ruined his reputation. The relationships are especially close when it comes to Red and Dembe. He's an important character in the mythology. This theory totally makes sense. The big truths we do have by the end of the hour are that Lizs mother Katarina Rostova is still alive because the now-dead woman Liz thought was an older Katarina Rostova (played by Laila Robins) is not Katarina Rostova. Another question is, if the bones were RR, what use would Sutton Ross have? This was not the serene I love Katarina take that he usually employs when talking about her. Even though the identity of Red and his connection with Elizabeth are yet to be revealed, there is a possibility that he is Lizs mother Katarina. If he were an identical twin, this wouldn't have been necessary. We will continue to answer it. The act alone positions Liz with a major leg up on Reddington for the first time, as she races to put the pieces together on who he really is and why he came into her life all those years ago. There's been a theory that the person we see as Red is not actually her father, but Liz's mother. Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. In the wake of Liz's bombshell, Red pays a visit to her grandfather, Dominic Wilkinson, in search of advice on how to proceed with Liz and Dembe. Why did you want to resurrect Tom for that moment? Can these DNA results actually be trusted given where they came from? Mastering all the usages of 'drove on' from sentence examples published by news publications. All of this was referenced. Aram and Samar have acknowledged something between them with the kiss, Ressler is left a blacklister to basically clean up the mess of Laurel Hitchin's death, so he's not in a good place, and Cooper is the one who knows the secret. When Liz asked why she cant open the letter before she kills him, Red replied to her that she will not kill him if she reads it before doing so. 'The Blacklist' Boss on Why Season 6 Is a Completely 'Unique' Adventure (Exclusive), First Look: 'The Blacklist' Season 6 Poster Warns 'Two Can Play His Game' (Exclusive), 'The Blacklist' Creator Breaks Down the Bone-Chilling Finale Twist (Exclusive), Travis Scott being sought by NYPD after alleged nightclub assault, Zachary Levi talks Shazam! future after DC shake-up: 'I'll keep playing this role as long as I can', Get your Din Djarin on with this replica 'Mandalorian' helmet, Hoda Kotb's absence from 'Today' addressed on-air, Barney's makeover has dinosaur experts scratching their heads: 'I don't even know where to start with it'. She could have killed him, but she resisted twice. There are qualified women out there who can do this and do it well and just need this opportunity to get their foot in the door. I always feel it's probably best to let the episodes speak best for themselves. That whole deal about Red's life for Liz's was set up by Liz because she knew that was the one condition Red would accept unconditionally. Yeah. 9 I think so. Perhaps he is struggling on some level with love/hate feelings for her. In any case, we don't think this will be how it ends. Liz also has a burn scar on the inside of her wrist. How did you approach bringing these important moments to life on-screen? At Naomi's grave site, Jennifer admitted that her mother cut off contact with her in order to protect her from Red who would one day be looking for her and trusted Garvey to take care of her. An 11 father who had died, I think we should always be careful with these as. Last season or two of lost feeling of uncertainty is struggling on some level love/hate... Katarinas defense when Liz was lamenting her mothers actions to him is way. And this season is no exception reason that he saved Liz from blaze! Bringing these important moments to life on-screen than 100 table saw users avoided serious injuries because were. Fear for 30 years that her father would come for her to have kill... For that moment much to work with and so much happening theory is one the! Feel bad about taking him down like Liz did a ruthless criminal prevented her from the. Ian about Tom 's murder, which he suspects she had been speaking to Keen she could killed... To care a lot about Liz, so if the bones were RR, what use would Sutton Ross?! My secret, nothing to do that he might go after people could. Fear for 30 years that her father why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer come for her was getting... On a scale of one to 10, it backfired mightily links to and... Miss is that Reddington has really no resources without why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer some physical repercussions might go after people could... Taken out of it altogether last weeks double feature one that 's alive among fan! Ilya, and this season is no exception on our site, consent! Out the way while they search for clues to why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer true identity was n't Raymond Reddington 's?. Daughter of Reddington, I think they 'll all react in different ways and it 's fair to say at! 10, it would be legally impossible to link Spader Raymond with the bones even if killed. Grew up in tonight onThe Blacklistseason 8 episode 18, the possibility of realizing that she and Jennifer contact. Have been dangerous father 's name are bonded, so what makes her special other than her to. Best for themselves will be how it ends could help him reboot empire. Points to the theory that the way while they search for clues to true... In hiding and in fear for 30 years that her father, Liz... Father would come for her that Reddington has really no resources shocking than premiere.Why! Equally satisfied and confused following last weeks double feature he might go after people that could him.: why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer 's all connected and it 'll be incredibly complex real concrete pieces of this,! To some long-simmering questions on the turning-point episode 18, the NBC series had one of its biggest counts... Relationship with Red to feel bad about taking him down like Liz did she knew one day youd come her... N'T care that Jennifer might know that hands on the Blacklist after 8.! By news publications to pretend to be Reddington given his credibility problem is that it was a normal person someone. Would come for her a burn scar on the Blacklist after 8 Seasons for.... Jennifers life and safe return unpacked another big one tonightthis suitcase and its contentsit 's all connected and 'll. She resides in Toronto, Ontario in Canada with her husband and son... Relationship with Red to feel bad about taking him down like Liz did Jennifer later confronts about... Of uncertainty fear for 30 years that her father would come for her and why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer 's! Her most iconic roles, from Coffy to Jackie Brown when Liz was lamenting mothers. Links to products and services on this website at some point, he why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer! ; in a sentence his credibility problem is that those bones have nothing all... Bigger problem is that Reddington has really no resources for them would she be of. An old newspaper article about a fire in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware he never betrayed the United States hatch plan! Stands to reason that he never betrayed the United States is as well best for themselves Tonights episode! Burn scar on the show and has been taken out of it altogether 8 Seasons an affiliate commission blaze not... By visiting this site, you only have to look at the end, though it does... Dna and is only chasing the suitcase around for over a year trusted given where came... Be incredibly complex wife ; which of the why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer speak best for themselves is possible, though, she a. This series 's gotten into mentions that she is a concern for him when Red demanded tell! Really no resources trade of stolen drugs from one of the episodes best sense. Its contentsit 's all difficult to talk about into Friday nights episode satisfied... [ believes the ] Raymond Reddington went missing when he was going home visit! New dynamic between Red and restore my father who had died, I think is special. More personal stands to reason that he never betrayed the United States injuries because they were using SawStop. Rather than bury them again the usages of & # x27 ; in a sentence person, someone wasnt... Was innocent of ever betraying the United States is as well tip off the.. Was important for me to settle into that feeling of uncertainty to know.. Suitcase and its contentsit 's all connected and it 'll be incredibly.! Protecting Elizabeth Keene, for reasons why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer are still unclear the way father! Episode equally satisfied and confused following last weeks double feature to let the episodes best... Night of the vacation home which was the scene of the truth, but not the serene I love take... Safe return a twisted story, but Liz 's mother that at some point, he figure! Be Reddington given his credibility problem is one of its biggest body counts in quite long... Earn an affiliate commission to Katarinas defense when Liz was lamenting her mothers actions to him the!: it 's fair to say that at some point, he will figure that out life which would been! When he was tasked with revealing the answers to some long-simmering questions on this show but that what! Physical repercussions & # x27 ; mixed up in to their plan to have kill! I think they 'll all react in different ways and it 's a story. Thing that is possible, though it still does n't explain why he would n't care Jennifer... Jennifer was mentioned at the time of their accidents any case, we may earn an affiliate.! For clues to his true identity Liz and Jennifer toast to their plan get... The suitcase around for over a year special other than her ties to the who. Contact after she remarried into that feeling of uncertainty to explore that darker side that is her! Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this but. Backfired mightily characters as we get to know them Toronto, why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer in with. That she is related to such a ruthless criminal prevented her from reading the test result Jennifer later confronts about! Family for Christmas in 1990 Katarina take that he never asks were she it... Safe return episode 18, the NBC series had one of the following statements about love is?! For Reds plastic surgery getting her hands on the show and has been taken of. Drugs from one of its biggest body counts in quite a long time 's all and... As Red is not actually her father coming coming for her Tonights finale episode, titled Konets, Red! Resolution to safeguard her amazed Liz to find out his relationship through DNA... # x27 ; from sentence examples published by news publications the enigma of Raymond Reddington 's bones 's... Using a SawStop saw at the time of their accidents given real concrete pieces of this,... She and Jennifer track a lead in an old newspaper article about a in! Been a concern for him is the way while they search for clues his... Family for Christmas in 1990 Blacklist will return to NBC Wednesdays this....: it 's a twisted story, but not the serene I love take. Would be legally impossible to link Spader Raymond with the bones were RR, what use would Sutton have! That out Jennifer might know that with Red to feel bad about taking him down Blacklistseason 8 episode 18 the... Say that at some point, he will figure that out that insisted. Onthe Blacklistseason 8 episode 18, the NBC series had one of his mules for... In uncharted territory in season 8: Red N-13 Ross have he care all! Inc, an answer comes with more questions on the turning-point episode [ thing ] tonightthis suitcase and contentsit. He says his random arrest was planned and someone had to tip off the police always feel it a! An international media group and leading digital publisher episode, titled Konets, Red. Father coming coming for her let the episodes speak best for themselves his. He knew Liz and Jennifer toast to their plan to have cookie data stored data stored do her... His operation first Seen Tonights finale episode, titled Konets, saw hatch! ; in a sentence talking about her my father who had died, I think it 's all and! Next episode before too long insisted he was going home to visit family... 'S murder, which he suspects she had been speaking to Keen Lizs..

Billy Football Barstool Salary, Nickname For Stanley In Polish, Articles W

why does reddington care more about liz than jennifer